Chapter · The idea
Reductio ad absurdum
Reductio ad absurdum(Absurdity reasoning)
Definition
Reductio ad absurdum proves a claim by assuming its opposite and reasoning from that assumption until a contradiction or manifest absurdity follows — which shows the assumption must be false, and therefore the original claim true. Three moves: assume NOT-P, reason from it consistently, arrive at something impossible; since NOT-P cannot hold, P must.
Memory hook
“Assume the opposite; follow the logic; let it break itself.”
What it sounds like
- Suppose, for argument's sake, that the opposite were true...
- Follow that to its conclusion and you get a contradiction.
- If that were right, then X and not-X would both have to hold.
- The position defeats itself: assume it's true and it becomes false.